This treat pouch comes closest to perfect of any I have owned or tried and I’ve had quite a few. Love that the lining zips out and can be cleaned, that you can get a new one, that there is a fridge and/or “wet stuff” cup that fits. Love the loops for a carabiner or keys, love the poop bag compartment and I love the treat compartments. My only disappointment comes in that, if I put my phone in the zip pocket, then access to the treats is significantly affected, as is the volume for treats. It’s minor. I can carry my phone somewhere else, but worth mentioning. Otherwise, this thing is just wonderful. Opens and closes easily, holds a lot of 2 different kinds of treats, is well-made, durable, not obtrusive and easy to wear. Not disappointed at all.