These are advertised as made in USA. When I received them it says globally sourced. Now I find I cannot return them. This was a scam. I would never feed to my dogs. It could be from China. Too many dogs have died from food from China and other places not from the USA. Don't buy from this company.

Unfortunately, this brand of bully sticks gave my dog the runs. I will go back to buying my usual brand of bully sticks which are a little more expensive but do not make my dog sick.

Same problem I have run into with similar items. They smell awful after a couple of hours of chewing and then my pup gets sick and some grisly, stinky stuff comes up.

I’m one of the minority who doesn’t mind the bully smell. Keeps my 2 Yorkies interested & they’re voracious chewers. I handed each a Willow stick: both dropped them after a moment & dug out older half chews. Purchased after reading myriad 5 star reviews & I carefully research whatever I buy for them. Wanted to escape that blue bag bully due to misrepresentation of size, rude customer service & extremely high price for a now poor quality product. These Willow sticks look fine & the packaging, while ripped partially open upon delivery, was lovely. I’ll have to donate as they’re of no interest to the fur kids.Really disappointed.

My 6 mo puppy wasn’t interested for long. Neither were 2 other adult dogs in household. They chewed the ends and then abandoned the rest. Tried multiple times.

This keeps my dog entertained but the smell is HORRIBLE. Not sure I’d recommend this product

Our 2, small dogs are somewhat picky eaters. We have to experiment with treats and I wish vendors offered a sample size package at reduced cost, just in case our dogs aren't in favor. It's risky ordering a larger and more expensive bag of treats not knowing if your dogs will like them or not. Once opened, I don't think you can return items like this. What we wind up doing is giving treats to other dog owners whose dog(s) love the treat or simply don't care what it is, they eat it.

I buy a lot of bully sticks, especially lately since my pup tore his cruciate ligament in both of his back legs and is on basically bed rest for months. So to keep him sane we buy lots of chew toys and bully sticks. These willow and I ones are not bad. I wouldn’t say they are the best bang for your buck, but they are decent quality for the price point. The bully sticks themselves last just as long as any other good brands we have used, though they were only mid thickness if I’m being honest. Overall though it’s not bad. I think if they were like 5-7 bucks less I would be more inclined to buy them again.

My boxer loves these but the cost is high.

My Morley kinda likes them but the smell is horrible.

These bully sticks were great quality. My dog has now finished the pack and has never had any digestive upset from any of it. He is a very aggressive chewer and this actually lasted a decent amount of time. I was very happily surprised. They also didn't smell to bad, and are very healthy for my best bud.

Tried to give this to my dog and he was not a fan of it. He kinda just gnawed at it and then left it alone. Normally he’d grab it and then walk off to his little area to chill with it. I attempted a few more times with a new one but it was the same reaction. Unfortunately it was a miss with my dude.

My dog enjoys these treats and they last longer than other chews we have purchased before.

My dogs love these bully sticks and they’re not too stinky which is always a bonus! I like to give my dogs one high value chew each week and these have been a hit! They last my lab puppy 1 hour and my 3 year old shepherd 30 minutes so it’s a longer lasting chew!

My pups are both big chewers and they loved these. Takes them a while to get through and they are large dogs. Smell is not too bad. No stomach issues from them, good quality.